Singing True
A 3D illustration of a steel-grey handpan with raised note fields and a green steel tongue drum with two small mallets, on a soft sand background

Handpans and drums · 4 min read

Handpan vs tongue drum: which one to buy

Handpans cost $249.99 to $1,999.90 in our listings and tongue drums $39.99 to $369.99. How they differ in build, notes, size and fit.

By Singing True. Last updated 2026-11-20.

In this guide
  1. How they are built
  2. Notes and scales
  3. How you play and what you hear
  4. Size and carrying
  5. Price
  6. Tuning risk
  7. So which should you buy?

Buy a tongue drum if you want the lowest price and the lowest risk. Buy a handpan if you want a bigger instrument with a wider range and you are happy to spend well over $1,000, or at least a few hundred. In our listings, handpans ran from $249.99 to $1,999.90 and tongue drums from $39.99 to $369.99.

We have not played either one. This comparison uses seller pages and reference pages we read on 2026-11-20. For a quick side by side, see our handpan vs tongue drum comparison page. This guide is the longer explanation.

How they are built

A handpan is two metal half-shells joined together, per Wikipedia. The top has a central tone field with at least seven more around it, and the underside has an opening. You play it with your hands.

A steel tongue drum starts as an enclosed steel shell, and the first ones came from propane tanks. Seven to ten tongues are cut into the top, and each is tuned by changing its length or adding weights, per Wikipedia. The shell is closed, and sound comes out through the slits.

So the key difference is where the note comes from: a shaped dome on a handpan, a cut tongue on a tongue drum.

A 3D illustration of a green steel tongue drum with two small mallets, on a soft sage background
A green steel tongue drum with two small mallets. An illustration from our own 3D model, not a photo of a product we tested.

Notes and scales

Both can be tuned to a named scale, and neither can be retuned by you. D Kurd, the D natural minor scale, shows up in both families. We saw it on the Meinl handpan and on the Meinl octave tongue drum.

Handpans in our listings had a stated 6 to 10 notes. The Meinl lists 10 tones, the Sela lists eight, and the X8 lists six. Tongue drums listed six or eight notes, plus a bass note on one. For a note-by-note look at D Kurd, read the handpan buying guide.

One thing to watch: Wikipedia says tongue drums are often tuned to pentatonic scales, and the six inch Meinl Mini lists a C pentatonic major layout. A pentatonic layout limits what you can play, but it also limits wrong notes.

How you play and what you hear

A handpan is played with the hands, as the name says. A tongue drum is played with fingers or with mallets, and the Meinl Octave listing says exactly that. Wikipedia calls the tongue drum's tone bell-like. One handpan seller, Cosmos Handpan, says each note on a D Kurd handpan blooms into a sustained resonance. That is a seller's description, and we have no recordings of either yet.

What the box adds also differs. The Meinl handpan ships with two removable sound tubes, a protection cover and a padded bag. The tongue drums we read ship with mallets and a bag, and the Medium Octave adds three silicone feet.

Size and carrying

The listings we read:

  • X8 handpan: 18 inches across, 8.5 inches tall, 4.85 pounds.
  • Sela handpan: 22.44 inches across, 12.57 pounds.
  • Meinl handpan: 22 inches across.
  • Meinl Mini tongue drum: 6 inches.
  • 10 inch tongue drums: Compact, Medium Octave and Pearl.

We found no weights on the tongue drum pages. A drum maker, Hluru, says a 12 inch drum should weigh at least 2.5 to 3 kg. That gives a rough idea of what a good steel drum feels like, though ours are 10 inches or smaller.

Plainly: a 6 inch tongue drum goes in a bag, and a 22 inch handpan needs a padded pack and a flat place to sit.

Price

Type Lowest we read Highest we read
Handpan $249.99 (X8, 18 inch) $1,999.90 (Meinl, 10 tone)
Tongue drum $39.99 (Meinl Mini) $369.99 (Meinl Octave D Kurd)

The two ranges overlap only slightly: the cheapest handpan is $249.99, and the Pearl tongue drum was $249 (sold out). The priciest tongue drum, $369.99, is $1,629.91 less than the priciest handpan (we subtracted the listed prices). Details sit on the handpan price page and the tongue drum price page.

Tuning risk

Both have a cheap end, and both have complaints. One handpan seller says quality handpans hold within 5 cents and budget ones often arrive 30 to 40 cents off and may not be retunable. A tongue drum maker says cheap drums miss by 15 to 30 cents. Both are sellers, and we did not measure either.

A handpan costs more to get wrong. A $39.99 drum that disappoints is a small loss. A $249.99 handpan with drifting notes, or a $1,299.90 one that is not as described, is a bigger one. Check the return policy first. The Sela page lists a two year warranty but says it requires the original dated receipt and does not transfer.

So which should you buy?

Buy a tongue drum if:

  • You are not sure you will keep playing.
  • You want something small.
  • You want to spend under $400.

Buy a handpan if:

  • You have already tried one and want more notes.
  • You are buying a long-term instrument and can pay for a named maker.
  • You have the space and a good bag.

If you are unsure, start with a tongue drum in a scale you could match later. Then use the tongue drum buying guide to choose one. Our guide on buying a used gong or handpan covers the used route if the price of a new handpan is the sticking point. All listings are on our instruments page.

Frequently asked questions

Is a tongue drum a cheap handpan?

Not exactly. They are different instruments. A handpan is two joined metal shells with tone fields hammered into the top. A tongue drum has slits cut into the top to form tongues. Wikipedia says the first hank drum was inspired in part by the Hang's tone layout.

Which is better for a beginner?

For most beginners on a budget, a tongue drum. The tongue drums we read cost $39.99 to $369.99 and most listed eight or fewer notes in a named scale. A handpan is a larger spend, and its scale cannot be changed.

Can I play a handpan and a tongue drum together?

Yes, if the scales and reference pitch match. A D Kurd handpan and a D Kurd tongue drum share a scale. Check that both use the same tuning standard, such as 440 Hz.

Do they hold their tuning?

We did not test any. Sellers say quality ones stay within 5 cents and cheap ones drift. One seller says budget handpans can arrive 30 to 40 cents off, and a drum maker says cheap tongue drums miss by 15 to 30 cents.

Products around

Listings that match this guide

Real listings from sellers, with the price and stock as we last saw them. We have not handled these ourselves.

  • Handpans
  • Tongue drums

Keep going

More to read, and the numbers

One calm email now and then. What to buy, what to skip.